Chris Garvey’s latest piece on why he writes is raw, honest, and much in line with many other writers’ reasons for creating art. While the life experiences vary greatly, the driving force remains the same. His piece brings to mind a passage from the out-of-print satirical novel by the great Aldous Huxley, entitled Those Barren Leaves. – Christopher Stoddard, Editor
Excerpt from Those Barren Leaves
By Aldous Huxley
To be torn between divided allegiances is the painful fate of almost every human being. Pull devil, pull baker; pull flesh, pull spirit; pull love, pull duty; pull reason and pull hallowed prejudice. The conflict, in its various forms, is the theme of every drama. For though we have learnt to feel disgust at the spectacle of a bullfight, an execution or a gladiatorial show, we still look on with pleasure at the contortions of those who suffer spiritual anguish. At some distant future date, when society is organized in a rational manner so that every individual occupies the position and does the work for which his capacities really fit him, when education has ceased to instill into the minds of the young fantastic prejudices instead of truths, when the endocrine glands have been taught to function in perfect harmony and diseases have been suppressed, all our literature of conflict and unhappiness will seem strangely incomprehensible; and our taste for the spectacle of mental torture will be regarded as an obscene perversion of which decent men should feel ashamed. Joy will take the place of suffering as the principal theme of art; in the process, it may be, art will cease to exist. A happy people, we now say, has no history; we might add that happy individuals have no literature. The novelist dismisses in a paragraph his hero’s twenty years of happiness; over a week of misery and spiritual debate he will linger through twenty chapters. When there is no more misery, he will have nothing to write about. Perhaps it will be all for the best.
Melancholy: My Muse, My Mentor
By Chris Garvey
As most know or could imagine, depression is depressing. But it can also be pretty inspiring, too. What it inspires varies of course, but if you’re lucky, from the tears, hangovers and lowered libido, you may acquire a little bit of creative stimulation.
Nature is a muse. Lovers, drugs and alcohol can be as well, but love and drugs wear off. One good thing about Seasonal Affective Disorder, or being dejected or a chemical comedown is that you’re left with something: a shitty feeling. And that shitty feeling can proliferate and wreak havoc on your life, or it can motivate you to channel it somehow—whether with a pen, brush, accordion or microscope.
When I’m content or relatively happy, I’m uninspired and bored. At first, doing things that normal-functioning people do is like a breath of fresh air. Hitting the gym three times a week is invigorating; food shopping and cooking is rewarding and cheaper and healthier than eating out. But the allure soon fades. And while friends tell me to embrace these periods of relative peace-of-mind, I just can’t. I crave the ups and downs, the penchant for sad songs, the abrupt crying spells and the drinking alone in bed. It’s fucked up but it’s just the way it is.
I’m happy to see some phony sense of happiness slip from my grasp. I wouldn’t be writing this, and you wouldn’t be reading it if I was out enjoying a fairly well-balanced existence. I’d be too satiated with going to the gym and cooking and sex and nightlife, and too worn out from the exercise, sex and partying to muster up the energy, desire and concentration to jot down even a paragraph or two.
Whether scribbled, splattered or screamed, the best art (or at least in my opinion, as ill-informed as it may be) comes from either a period of misery or a life’s worth. With no sadness and inner turmoil, your emotions are stale and conventional. This is a fact, I think, so it makes sense that without the melancholy, one’s songs, sculpture or poetry would be boring, banal and clichéd.
‘Muse’ reminds me of ‘mentor’—both of which I’ve never had, not in human form, anyway. Both muses and mentors have been extremely influential on world history and on modern-day pop culture. Without Eric Clapton falling in love with George Harrison’s wife, he would have had no muse and we’d have no ‘Layla.’ And without Oprah nurturing the career of Dr. Phil, he wouldn’t have an $80-million a year salary, even though we’d be a lot better off without his bloviation.
So while I may never have an overwhelmingly passionate and illicit affair with the wife of my best friend who also happens to be a Beatle, I’ll always have a pool of depression from which to draw. And sure, I could use Oprah or some form of guidance in my life, but at this point it’s probably too late. I’m like an old dog that’s been stuck in the pound too long. I may have some potential, but who’s gonna choose me over an un-jaded puppy? I wouldn’t. My proclivity for realism and cynicism can get depressing. And mentors are usually in a good place in their life, so why would they jeopardize their career contentment and life’s achievements with someone like me? Again, I wouldn’t.
Hereditary conditions like schizophrenia and bipolar disorders can transfer onto generations through DNA. Life-tainting experiences like death, divorce or eviction can open the door to emotional hopelessness. These life moments can bring you to a dark place. But for some of us, depending on hereditary traits, childhood upbringing and one’s own adult life trajectory, it’s a comfortable place to be.
Without the blues, there’d be no B.B., Buddy or John Lee. Without heartbreak, there’d be no ‘Tracks of My Tears’ or the poetry of Sylvia Plath or Picasso’s blue period, and without anguish, we couldn’t draw from the existentialism of Sartre and the raw expression of Kurt Cobain. Sure, Cobain killed himself. Plath did, too. Van Gogh chopped off an ear after some chick dumped him. But what’s better, to live long and even-keeled and leave the world with nothing but a will and a headstone, or to shave off a few decades of life and inner-peace to create something that may move people? There’s no right answer, of course, but I know what mine is.
Huxley, Aldous. Those Barren Leaves. New York: Harper & Brothers, 1925.